Court denies Hill’s bid to halt execution

    posted Apr 23, 2013, 10:11 AM by GFADP staff

    Court denies Hill’s bid to halt execution

    BY BILL RANKIN 

    THE ATLANTA JOURNAL-CONSTITUTION

    Tuesday, April 23, 2013

     

    The federal appeals court in Atlanta has denied Warren Hill’s bid to halt his execution on grounds he is mentally retarded.

    By a 2-1 vote, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Hill’s claim challenged only his eligibility for a death sentence and not whether he is guilty of murder. For this reason, Hill cannot clear the narrow “actual innocence” exception that allows capital inmates to raise new claims after prior appeals had been exhausted, Judge Frank Hull wrote.

    Judge Rosemary Barkett issued a stinging dissent.

    “There is no question that Georgia will be executing a mentally retarded man because all seven mental health experts who have ever evaluated Hill, both the state’s and Hill’s, now unanimously agree that he is mentally retarded.”

    Hull was joined by Judge Stanley Marcus, who joined Barkett in February to halt Hill’s execution with less than an hour to spare. Hill had already been given a sedative to prepare for his lethal injection.

    Hill was sentenced to death for killing Joseph Handspike, an inmate serving a life sentence in the same southwest Georgia prison where Hill was incarcerated. Hill bludgeoned Handspike to death with a nail-studded wooden board as Handspike lay in his bed.

    At the time, Hill was already serving a life term for another murder; he had killed his 18-year-old girlfriend, Myra Wright, by shooting her 11 times in 1986.

    http://www.ajc.com/news/news/local/court-denies-hills-bid-to-halt-execution/nXTcS/

     

    GFADP Atlanta Chapter Meeting, 4/11 at 6:30pm

    posted Apr 9, 2013, 7:49 AM by GFADP staff

    Please join us for GFADP's Atlanta Chapter Meeting on Thursday April 11th at 6:30 PM at 730 Peachtree St. NE in the first floor conference room.  We will recap the legislative session and brainstorm ways to expose the challenges of Georgia's current burden of proof standard for folks with Intellectual Disability (formerly known as Mental Retardation).  We will also update folks on the MaryRuth Weir Fundraising Dinner.
     
    There is free parking in the back parking deck and we are one block from the North Ave MARTA station. 
     
    If you have any questions, please email Evelyn Lynn at evelyn@gfadp.org 

    SAVE THE DATE

    posted Apr 8, 2013, 11:04 AM by GFADP staff

    Please SAVE THE DATE for Georgians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty’s Annual Dinner in honor of two courageous women who dedicated their lives to work for justice and end the death penalty.

     

    The MaryRuth Weir Dinner and

    Silent Auction

    Thursday May 23rd at 6 pm

    Trinity Presbyterian Church

    3003 Howell Mill Road

    Atlanta, GA

     

    This year’s Human Rights Award in memory of Mary Ruth Weir will be awarded to longtime attorney and advocate Steve Bright, founder of the Southern Center for Human Rights.  The Martina Correia Courage Award will be awarded to Mrs. Rosalyn Rouse, Co-Director of the Community Organized Legal Advocate (COLA) Center in Savannah, GA.

     

    More information will follow regarding purchasing tickets or whole tables, silent auction items and program book ads. If you know you would like to reserve a ticket or table or if you have any questions, please contact GFADP at info@gfadp.org or (404) 602-2856.

    ACTION ALERT: Call your House Member

    posted Mar 22, 2013, 2:07 PM by Kathryn Hamoudah

    Friends,

    Unfortunately, We must report that moments ago, the Senate voted to pass HB 122 with the amendment that designates information related to the lethal injection process and the drugs used as state secrets.

    The House must now “Agree” or “Disagree” on the Senate version. It could be called at anytime on Monday, so please call your State Representative by 10am Monday and ask them to oppose the language in HB 122 that removes public scrutiny from the death penalty process. As citizens, we must be able to examine the actions of our government, particularly when it comes to the government’s most serious role of taking a person’s life.

    To identify the member of the Georgia House of Representatives that represents you, please visit:  VoteSmart.org and plug in your 9-digit zip code. To look up your 9-digit zip code, please visit: USPS.com ZIP Code Lookup. All members are also listed here: http://www.house.ga.gov/Representatives/en-US/HouseMembersList.aspx

    If HB 122 passes in its current form, it would arguably make everything about how the state carries out its gravest duty a state secret.  The Georgia Department of Corrections has said that due to drug shortages, it will soon have to rely upon compounding pharmacies to manufacture the Pentobarbital it needs for executions. HB 122 as written would shield everything about the process of manufacturing that drug from the public.  This is information that is critical for the public to be able to review, and it is imperative that we preserve transparency and accountability in the GA Department of Corrections. The passage of HB 122 as written will also likely lead to litigation, as in Texas, where a similarly over broad provision was struck down by the courts. 


    More information can be found in an article by Bill Rankin at the Atlanta Journal Constitution here and in a column buy Charlie Harper, editor of the conservative blog Peach Pundit here.

    ACTION ALERT: Senate set to gut transparency regarding lethal injection

    posted Mar 22, 2013, 11:40 AM by Kathryn Hamoudah   [ updated Mar 22, 2013, 11:42 AM ]

    Friends,

     

    We write today to ask you to take immediate action on a piece of legislation that impacts Georgia’s process of carrying out the death penalty.

     

    The Georgia legislature is rapidly advancing a bill that will shield Georgia’s lethal injection process from public scrutiny. On Wednesday, a last minute amendment was attached to House Bill 122, a bill that has nothing to do with the death penalty, that will designate as state secrets much information related to the lethal injection process and the drugs used.

     

    More information can be found in an article by Bill Rankin at the Atlanta Journal Constitution here and in a column buy Charlie Harper, editor of the conservative blog Peach Pundit here.

    The current version of the bill with this added language is not available online yet.

     

    As many of you know, the State of Georgia has come under a lot of scrutiny for its participation in the illegal importation and distribution of drugs used in executions. The Georgia Department of Corrections has proven that if anything they should have more oversight not less.

     

    It is critical that the Legislators and the Governor knows that we must preserve and protect accountability and transparency.  

                      

    HB 122 is on the floor TODAY.  Please contact your Georgia State Senator, Georgia State Representative and the Governor and tell them that you oppose HB 122 as amended by the Senate Judiciary Non Civil committee. To identify the member of the Georgia House of Representatives and Senator that represents you, please visit:  VoteSmart.org and plug in your 9-digit zip code. To look up your 9-digit zip code, please visit: USPS.com ZIP Code Lookup.

     

    If HB 122 passes in its current form, it would arguably make everything about how the state carries out its gravest duty a state secret.  The Georgia Department of Corrections has said that due to drug shortages, it will soon have to rely upon compounding pharmacies to manufacture the Pentobarbital it needs for executions. HB 122 as written would shield everything about the process of manufacturing that drug from the public.  This is information that is critical for the public to be able to review, and it is imperative that we preserve transparency and accountability in the GA Department of Corrections. The passage of HB 122 as written will also likely lead to litigation, as in Texas, where a similarly over broad provision was struck down by the courts. 



    Thanks for your help in advance!

     

    Breaking News: State experts change opinions in Warren Hill's case

    posted Feb 14, 2013, 10:44 AM by Kathryn Hamoudah

    By Bill Rankin

    Atlanta Journal Constitution

    Three experts used by the state to prove condemned killer Warren Hill was not mentally disabled — and thus ineligible for execution — now say they were in error, according to sworn affidavits released Thursday.

    The revelations were disclosed shortly before Hill’s scheduled execution on Tuesday by lethal injection. His lawyers are asking the U.S. Supreme Court to halt the execution and say they will soon ask the State Board of Pardons and Paroles to reconsider Hill’s request for clemency.

    “There is now consensus among all experts that Mr. Hill is mentally retarded,” said Brian Kammer, one of Hill’s attorneys. “The prospect of his execution under such circumstances should shock the conscience.”

    Lauren Kane, a spokeswoman for the state Attorney General’s Office, said her office had no immediate comment. She said the office’s lawyers will respond to Hill’s new claims when he files a petition in court.

    Hill sits on death row for fatally bludgeoning a fellow inmate with a wooden board. At the time, Hill was serving a life sentence at a southwest Georgia prison for killing his 18-year-old girlfriend.

    The former state experts, two psychiatrists and a psychologist, describe their evaluations of Hill in late 2000 as rush jobs. They also said they did not have all the information they needed to make a proper diagnosis.

    The doctors’ affidavits say that the scientific understanding of mental retardation has grown over the past dozen years, giving them better insights into evaluating a person such as Hill, who they initially believed was faking his mental disabilities.

    Hill’s case has already attracted national attention because two state court judges previously found that Hill was mentally retarded. But they said Hill could only prove it by a preponderance of the evidence — or that he was more likely than not mentally retarded.

    That’s not strong enough proof in Georgia, which is the only state in the country that requires capital defendants to clear a the most difficult legal threshold — proving it beyond a reasonable doubt.

    In 2002, the U.S. Supreme Court banned the execution of the mentally retarded.

    The key hearing to determine whether Hill was mentally retarded occurred in December 2000, when the state called on its three experts to refute Hill’s claims. They all testified that they believed Hill did not meet the criteria for mental retardation.

    But Thomas Sachy, a forensic psychiatrist who worked part-time at Central State Hospital in Milledgeville and who evaluated Hill for one hour in 2000, said he contacted Hill’s attorneys last July after reading media reports about the case. Concerned his initial conclusions were unreliable, he said he wanted to take another look at his original notes and reports as well as other evidence from the voluminous court record.

    Sachy noted he did not have experience in 2000 evaluating patients for mental retardation but has since treated many patients who were mentally retarded.

    “I do not believe now that Mr. Hill was deliberately feigning a cognitive disorder in 2000, and I believe that his responses to my questions were consistent with mild mental retardation,” Sachy said.

    Sachy said he believes, to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty, that Hill meets the criteria because Hill had “significantly sub-average general intellectual functioning, associated with significant deficits in adaptive functioning, with the onset before the age of 18.”

    James Gary Carter, the former Clinical Director of Forensic Services at Central State Hospital, and Donald W. Harris, once a licensed psychologist at the hospital, also say they were in error when they testified Hill was not mentally retarded, according to their affidavits.

    http://www.ajc.com/news/news/local/state-experts-change-opinions-in-condemned-killers/nWPTB/

    Two execution warrants

    posted Feb 5, 2013, 10:38 AM by Kathryn Hamoudah

    We’re so sorry to share the news that two execution warrants just came down in Georgia: Warren Hill is set for Feb. 19-26 and Andrew Cook is set for Feb. 21-28.

     

    We are checking in with their lawyers and we’ll be in touch as soon as possible about next steps.

     

    This brazen act is reflective of the way the Department Corrections operates as though they aren’t accountable to anybody. We are here to remind them that there are thousands of Georgians who are opposed to state sanctioned killing.  

     

    As we shared yesterday, Georgia’s death penalty system was launched into national and international news in 2011 when the Georgia Department of Corrections’ illegal practice of purchasing lethal injection drugs from a fly-by-night shop behind a driving school in London was exposed, prompting the DEA to raid and seize the black market drugs.



    Decision in Warren Hill's Case

    posted Feb 4, 2013, 1:40 PM by GFADP staff


    As some of you might know, the Georgia Supreme Court ruled in an unanimous decision that the Department of Corrections was not subject to the Administrative Procedures Act when they changed their execution protocol the day before the state planned to execute Warren Hill.

     

    This decision lifts the temporary halt on executions that was in place and paves the way for execution warrants to be issued.

     

    We’ve included coverage of the decision below.

     

    As you know, Georgia’s death penalty system was launched into national and international news in 2011 when the Georgia Department of Corrections’ illegal practice of purchasing lethal injection drugs from a fly-by-night shop behind a driving school in London was exposed, prompting the DEA to raid and seize the black market drugs.

     

    We will keep you posted on any new developments.

     

       

    ###

     

    http://www.ajc.com/news/news/local/court-clears-way-for-execution-of-killer/nWFPJ/

    Monday, Feb. 4, 2013 @ 9:47 a.m.

     

    Court clears way for execution of killer

    By Bill Rankin | The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

     

    The Georgia Supreme Court on Monday rejected an appeal by a condemned inmate over a change in the state’s lethal-injection process, clearing the way for the man’s execution.

     

    In a unanimous opinion, the court approved the Department of Corrections decision to replace a three-drug execution cocktail with one drug. The court found the agency’s change was not subject to the Administrative Procedure Act, which requires public hearing before any such change may be made.

     

    On July 23, just two hours before Warren Hill was to be put to death, the state Supreme Court had halted the execution to give the court time to decide whether the Department of Corrections violated state law.

     

    A week earlier, the agency had delayed Hill’s execution to give it time to switch from three lethal-injection drugs to one, pentobarbital. One of the drugs the state had been using in lethal injections —- the paralytic pancuronium bromide —- had expired two weeks before Hill’s initially scheduled execution, according to records obtained by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution under the Open Records Act.

     

    Hill sits on death row for killing fellow inmate Joseph Handspike in 1990 when Hill was already serving a life sentence for killing his girlfriend. Hill’s capital case has attracted national attention because two judges hearing his appeals had found him more likely than not to be mentally disabled. But appeals courts declined to overturn the death sentence, saying Hill had failed to prove he was mentally disabled beyond a reasonable doubt, and thus ineligible for execution.

     

    / / / / /

     

    http://www.therepublic.com/view/story/c13e6415b80c4b53bdb1e5bb6dbf8d67/GA--Georgia-Death-Penalty

    February 04, 2013 - 9:07 am EST | via The Republic

     

    Georgia Supreme Court rules against death row inmate in case involving execution method

    THE ASSOCIATED PRESS 

        

    TLANTA — The Supreme Court of Georgia has ruled against a death row inmate who accused prison officials of violating state procedures by failing to hold a public notice hearing before changing the state's execution procedure.

     

    In a ruling released Monday, the court ruled that the decision to replace a three-drug cocktail with one drug for executions is not subject to the Georgia Administrative Procedure Act, so it does not require public hearings before making the change.

     

    With Monday's unanimous decision, the high court lifted the stay of execution it granted last July to Warren Lee Hill hours before he was to die by lethal injection for the 1990 killing of a prison inmate.

     

    Hill was set to be executed July 18. The day before, the Department of Corrections announced the change in its execution protocol and delayed Hill's execution until July 23.

     

    Hill's lawyers challenged the new execution protocol. They said the change was not preceded by a 30-day notice period as required by the Georgia Administrative Procedure Act -- meaning the new method is invalid.

     

    State lawyers countered that the injection protocol is part of the Department of Corrections' standing operating procedures that can be changed by the department commissioner without additional steps.

     

    A few hours before Hill was to be executed, the Georgia Supreme Court stayed the execution so it could determine whether corrections officials broke the law.

     

    Hill was convicted in the 1990 beating death of fellow inmate Joseph Handspike.

     

    He "removed a two-by-six board embedded with nails that served as a sink leg in the prison bathroom and, as Handspike slept, pounded him in his head and chest with the board as onlooking prisoners pleaded with him to stop," Monday's Supreme Court ruling states.

     

    / / / / /

    http://www.albanyherald.com/news/2013/feb/04/justices-ruling-lifts-stay-against-condemned-man/

    February 4, 2013 | The Albany Herald

     

    Justices' ruling lifts stay against condemned man

    Warren Lee Hill was convicted in Lee County of killing a fellow prison inmate.

     

    ATLANTA — The Georgia Supreme Court has issued a ruling Monday that effectively lifts the stay of execution of a man convicted of killing a fellow prison inmate in Lee County in 1990.

     

    Lawyers for Warren Lee Hill had challenged the Georgia Department of Correction's decision to abandon the three-drug cocktail previously used to execute inmates with one drug without going through a lengthy series of public hearings as required under the Georgia Administrative Procedure Act.

     

    In a unanimous opinion Monday, the justices ruled that the change in drugs is not subject to the act and lifted the stay of execution previously granted for Hill.

     

    “Specifically, this case concerns who is legally authorized to select the drug or drugs to be used in executions in Georgia and how that choice may be made,” the opinion says. “However, this case could also affect the remaining myriad of management decisions made throughout Georgia’s prison system,” as it concerns “when those decisions must be made directly by the Board of Corrections in its policy-making role versus when they may be left to the statutorily-granted management prerogatives of the Commissioner of Corrections and the Department of Corrections that he manages.”

     

    According to the Georgia Supreme Court, Hill received the death penalty in 1991 after a Lee County jury convicted him of murder in the 1990 bludgeoning death of a fellow prison inmate, Joseph Handspike. Hill and Handspike were inmates at the Lee County Correctional Institute. According to the facts of the case, Hill was already serving a life sentence for murdering his former 18-year-old girlfriend, Myra Sylvia Wright, when on the morning of Aug. 17, 1990, he removed a two-by-six board embedded with nails that served as a sink leg in the prison bathroom and, as Handspike slept, pounded him in his head and chest with the board as onlooking prisoners pleaded with him to stop. Handspike later died at the hospital.

     

    In 1993, the Georgia Supreme Court upheld his conviction and death sentence.

     

    Last July, the Lee County Superior Court entered an order for execution during a period of time between July 18 and July 25, 2012. Hours before his execution, the Georgia Supreme Court issued the stay and decided to hear his case.

     

    In today’s opinion, the high court has affirmed the lower court’s ruling and lifted Hill’s stay of execution, concluding that the Board of Corrections “is not specifically required by statute to make rules governing the particular subject of lethal injection procedures….” Under the Georgia Code, the board “shall adopt rules governing the assignment, housing, working, feeding, clothing, treatment, discipline, rehabilitation, training and hospitalization of all inmates coming under its custody.” Hill’s attorneys argued that under this duty to adopt rules governing the “treatment” administered to prison inmates, the board is required to adopt rules governing executions, and “rules” adopted by the board are subject to the Administrative Procedure Act. “We disagree for several reasons,” the high court says in its 21-page opinion. For one thing, the word “treatment” here does not carry the broader meaning of how inmates are handled overall, but rather refers more narrowly to their medical care. “Lethal injection may involve a drug or drugs that could be used in medical care; however, using a massive dose of a drug with the sole intention of causing immediate death cannot, we think, be reasonably described as medical care,” the opinion says.

     

    The order Monday does not state when Hill may be executed.

     

    / / / / /

    Thank you!

    posted Dec 31, 2012, 9:37 AM by Kathryn Hamoudah

    Friends,

    Thank you for all your support this year. Without you we simply wouldn't be able to do the work we do without you. Thanks to your generosity, we're just $800 away from our goal!

    We're writing today to remind you that if you were considering a donation to us this year, you have until midnight tonight to make it. And don't forget that thanks to the generosity of the National Coalition to Abolish the Death Penalty (NCADP), every donation will be matched dollar for dollar. Please consider making as generous a gift as you can $50, $100, $500, or even $1000.

    Thanks again, and all the best for 2013.



    2012 Newsletter: TOGETHER WE ARE STRONGER

    posted Dec 7, 2012, 1:20 PM by GFADP staff

    Click here to read GFADP's 2012 Newsletter

    1-10 of 159